But what causes this difference in insurance outcome? Here, we have presented a detailed breakdown.
Same Incident, Different Starting Point
The first difference is the insured value of each car. A luxury model usually has a higher market value and more expensive parts. A budget car tends to have lower part costs and simpler systems.
When an accident happens, the insurer looks at the estimated repair bill in relation to the insured value and the current market value of each vehicle. The same impact can therefore lead to a large bill for one car and a more moderate one for the other.
The structure of each car insurance policy also matters. One owner may have selected a basic plan with few add‑ons, while the other has chosen broader protection with several extra covers. Even when both are labelled as comprehensive, the details inside can be quite different.
Variations in Cover and Add‑ons
Under a comprehensive car insurance policy, own‑damage and third‑party liabilities are usually covered, subject to terms and exclusions.
How Insurance Companies Assess Damage and Value
Insurance companies use a combination of repair estimates, market value assessments, and depreciation calculations to determine claim settlements. For luxury cars, even minor damage can result in high repair bills due to specialized parts and labor. In contrast, budget cars often have more readily available and less expensive parts, leading to lower repair costs. Insurers also consider the car's age, mileage, and previous accident history, which can further influence the final payout.
Within that framework, add‑ons such as zero depreciation, consumables cover, engine protection, and return‑to‑invoice can change how much is finally paid by the insurer and how much remains with the owner.
A luxury car owner might be more inclined to select several add‑ons to manage high parts and labour costs. A budget car owner may decide to keep the premium lower and accept more risk.
When both face the same accident, the owner with more add‑ons may see a higher proportion of the bill settled by the insurer, while the other may pay more towards parts, consumables or specific sections that are not covered.
Impact of Repair Networks and Labour
Repair choices also influence the outcome. Luxury vehicles often need specialised workshops or brand‑authorised service centres.
Labour rates and part prices at such facilities are generally higher. A budget car can often be repaired at a wider range of workshops, including many that are part of an insurer’s cashless network.
If both owners use cashless garages, the pattern is the same, but the amounts differ. The luxury car bill may cross thresholds that lead to discussions on repair versus total loss, or on replacement options for costly panels and electronics.
The budget car repair may remain within a narrower range, even when the damage looks similar to the eye.
Deductibles, Limits and Non-Covered Items
Another reason outcomes look different is the way deductibles and limits apply. Both policies are likely to include a compulsory excess, and some may include a voluntary excess chosen by the owner. These amounts stay with the policyholder regardless of vehicle type.
Non‑covered items also play a role. If one owner has a consumables add‑on and the other does not, fluids, small parts and certain materials may be reimbursed for one claim but not the other.
If one vehicle has accessories or modifications that are not declared, related damage might not be covered. In luxury cars, accessories and optional features tend to be more expensive, so gaps in declaration or cover show up more clearly in the final figures.
Insurers design products to meet a wide range of needs across segments. A company such as HDFC ERGO, for example, offer car insurance options that include a high maximum NCB percentage, access to a large number of cashless garages across the country and a choice of add‑ons that can be combined differently for different types of cars.
Wrapping Up
When both owners understand, in advance, how their policies are built, the different claim outcomes are less surprising. Knowing the insured value, deductibles, add‑ons chosen, and repair options makes it easier to predict which parts of a bill are likely to be covered and which will remain their responsibility. It also helps them decide, at each renewal, whether to adjust their cover as the vehicle ages, usage changes, or budgets shift.
Practical Tips for Navigating Insurance Claims
No matter what type of car you own, it's important to document the accident thoroughly, collect all necessary information, and communicate clearly with your insurer. Keep records of repair estimates and ask for itemized bills. For luxury car owners, consider policies that offer original manufacturer parts and specialized repair options. Budget car owners may benefit from policies with lower deductibles or cash settlement options. Always review your policy details before an accident occurs.
Sponsored article